
IdeAmigos: Comparing User-Orchestrated and System-Orchestrated Multi-Agent Brainstorming
(Under review at CHI 2027)
, Jeongeon Park
- Compared user-orchestrated and system-orchestrated brainstorming with the same four AI agents to examine creative outcomes, agency, intent alignment, psychological ownership, and coordination burden.
- Conducted a within-subjects study with 16 students with HCI or UX coursework experience, using two counterbalanced 30-minute brainstorming sessions.
- User orchestration received higher average user-experience ratings, without statistically significant differences; creative outcomes varied by task, with broadly similar semantic diversity.
- Identified design implications for balancing orchestration control with attention, adapting support to tasks and stages, revisiting ideas, and encouraging critical engagement.







